Home Server: Boot & Storage Recommendations, please

This post was originally published on this site

tl;dr

 

I have a basic home server with one NVMe drive, multiple SSDs, and multiple (SATA) HDDs, plus multiple USB3 ports and an SD card reader.

What’s the best boot / storage configuration for good performance with a basic degree of resilience? Thank you.

 

More

 

First, a disclaimer:

In an ideal world I’d have multiple hosts, for redundancy and failover. I’d also have separate storage: a well-spec’d FreeNAS box with a decent SAS card and a healthy chunk of ECC memory, serving shares via NFS. But at the moment I don’t have those things; I’m trying to do the best I can with what I’ve got.

So:

 

BOOT

 

I’ve read some documentation and blog posts. I’ve seen recommendations to boot from SD card, but I’m a bit wary of this: my experience with SBCs (e.g. RPi) is that after a while – when the card starts to run out of write cycles – they can fail in interesting and unpredictable ways. I have experience booting OSes from USB as well (see FreeNAS, above); do you think this would be a better option?

 

STORAGE

 

In terms of “speed”: NVMe > SSD > HDD

 

…So I’m assuming:

 

SSDs (mirrored): VMs

HDDs (mirrored): other persistent data

NVMe: cache and ephemeral data (etc.)

 

Does that make sense? Is there a better way?

 

Thank you for reading Apologies for a long post.

 

P.S. Out-of-scope-but-still-relevant: the server has 32G of (non-ECC) RAM, and 5 x 1G Intel ethernet. My goal is to host no more than three “permanent” VMs (e.g. LAMP/LEMP), plus occasional others for experiments I can’t do – or don’t want to do – in a container / virtual environment. Thanks again.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.